The European Parliament has backed EU rules labelling investments in gas and nuclear power plants as climate-friendly, throwing out an attempt to block the law that has exposed deep rifts between countries over how to fight climate change.
The vote paves the way for the European Union proposal to pass into law, unless 20 of the bloc’s 27 member states decide to oppose the move, which is seen as very unlikely.
The new rules will add gas and nuclear power plants to the EU “taxonomy” rulebook from 2023, enabling investors to label and market investments in them as green.
Out of 639 lawmakers present, 328 opposed a motion that sought to block the EU gas and nuclear proposals.
Today the EU made a terrible decision. Turning its back on the advice of climate scientists, ignoring you and the calls from groups all across Europe, and giving a massive boost to Russia’s war chest. #NotMyTaxonomy #EUTaxonomy https://t.co/QEJP6Qqs2Q pic.twitter.com/M4ODAXa04k
— Greenpeace (@Greenpeace) July 6, 2022
The result will be a relief to the European Commission, which proposed the rules in February after more than a year of delay and intense lobbying from governments and industries.
The gas and nuclear rules have split EU countries, lawmakers and investors.
Brussels redrafted the rules multiple times, flip-flopping over whether to grant gas plants a green tag.
Its final proposal fuelled fierce debate about how to hit climate goals amid a crisis over dwindling Russian gas supplies.
Gas is a fossil fuel that produces planet-warming emissions (but far less than coal) and some EU states see it as a temporary alternative in the shift away from dirtier coal.
Nuclear energy is free from CO2 emissions but produces radioactive waste.
Nuclear backers such as France say it is vital to meet emissions-cutting goals, while opponents cite concerns about waste disposal.
Slovakian Prime Minister Eduard Heger said the vote result was good for energy security and emissions-cutting targets.
“We’ll remain on the way to climate neutrality by 2050,” he said in a tweet.
Luxembourg and Austria, which both oppose nuclear power, have also warned against labelling gas as green, saying they would challenge the law in the EU’s top court.
“It is neither credible, ambitious nor knowledge-based, endangers our future and is more than irresponsible,” Austrian climate minister Leonore Gewessler said.
Climate campaigners criticised the move, with Greenpeace saying it would also mount a legal challenge.
“This is a poor signal to the rest of the world that may undermine the EU’s leadership position on climate action,” said Anders Schelde, chief investment officer at Danish pension fund AkademikerPension.
But industry groups welcomed the vote.
Ingbert Liebing, managing director of Germany’s local utility association VKU, called it “an important sign of the role of natural gas as a bridge to achieving climate goals”.
The EU taxonomy aims to clear up the murky world of sustainable investing, by ensuring any financial products making eco-friendly claims meet certain standards.
Gas plants, for example, must switch to low-carbon gases by 2035 and meet an emissions limit.
Before the vote, lawmakers had disagreed on the extent to which the law will impact financial markets, since it does not prohibit investments in activities without the green label.